Fight for Food Safety
Fight for Food Safety

Ask yourself: What would a jury think?

Life often presents us with some very difficult decisions. And, in many cases, the decisions we make can have some very serious consequences. In this context, it also stands to reason that the way in which we analyze information and make decisions will also play a significant role in the choices we make.

The same is true in our own profession. Every food processor wants to believe that the food it produces is as safe as it can be, and that any departure from this standard is exceptionally rare. But, the safety of a company’s food is only as good as the company’s food-safety decisions. And, in many instances, when a company is faced with a difficult food-safety choice, it will place more significance on information that supports what it wants to believe, while discounting information that runs contrary to its belief.

Let’s say, for instance, a company is faced with the difficult food-safety decision of recalling product for the presence of undeclared allergens. When making the decision regarding the scope of the recall, the company might discount evidence which runs contrary to the desired outcome (such as the actual level of allergens present or the scope of the potential contamination). That same company may also place more significance on information which suggests — perhaps incorrectly — the absence of a problem, such as pointing to questionable employee accounts (or other less reliable evidence) to show that the problem was limited to only a few, select batches (when, in fact, it was much broader).

So, when faced with such dilemmas, how should you process the information available and make your own food-safety decisions? Well, the answer is simple. Just ask yourself, “What would 12 jurors think?”

While it’s true under this scenario that your decision about whether to recall certain products, or about how much to recall, will not likely lead to future lawsuits or trial, it might. Imagine, for instance, that you limit the recall too narrowly, and someone becomes sick or even dies. Once a lawsuit is filed, there will be an unrelenting chorus of second-guessing: How could you have made such an incorrect decision? Or, why does your company put its own profits ahead of the safety of its customers? In this scenario, obviously, the opinions of 12 jurors will definitely matter.

But, even if a lawsuit is not filed, the same watchwords will ensure that you are consistently making the right decision in all aspects of your profession. This is because a juror is no different than you or me. And, in reality, it someday could be you or me. So, imagine you were a juror at trial asked to judge your own choices?

If you would be proud of those decisions sitting as a juror, then you can always be proud standing behind those decisions as a professional.

Did you enjoy this article? Click here to subscribe to National Provisioner.

Recent Articles by Shawn Stevens

You must login or register in order to post a comment.



Image Galleries


Brenneman analyzes Butterball’s new animal care, well-being program

Rod Brenneman, CEO of Butterball, discusses his company's new Animal Care and Well-Being Program, his company's certification by the American Humane Association and further animal-handling initiatives, all officially announced in September 2013.

More Podcasts

National Provisioner


April 2015

The April issue of NP offers cover story: Monogram Foods: Intrinsic growth.

Table Of Contents Subscribe

Independent Processor


April 2015

IP's April issue freatures cover story: An open book, Kiolbassa Provision’s management style stresses a values-based corporate culture and total transparency for its employees.

Table Of Contents Subscribe

Provisioner Store

The National Provisioner Source Book

The Sourcebook is an exclusive buyer’s guide and reference tool for product and supplier information in the meat, poultry and seafood marketplace.

More Products


A complete reference guide to supplies. Go to NP's Sourcebook now to check out the latest and greatest in the meat and poultry processing business.


Facebook icon Twitter icon  YouTube iconLinkedIn icon google +


Provisioner Prime is a twice weekly electronic newsletter created by the editors of The National Provisioner. Provisioner Prime appears in your inbox every Tuesday and Thursday with a recap of the week's top news and trends. Provisioner Prime also offers you exclusive access to industry analysis, blogs, events, podcasts, videos, webinars and The National Provisioner feature articles. 

Sign up for Provisioner Prime HERE.