Commentary

Editor-In-Chief

Follow up: Penalize the real culprits, not BP innocents

July 30, 2010
By: Barbara Young


Photo by Kyle Young

I very much appreciate feedback from those of you who read my blog commentaries. I was especially moved by J.E.B.’s reaction to my comments concerning BP (“Don’t punish BP franchisees, posted July 7, 2010). You said you don’t wish to see mom-and-pop gas-station owners suffer for corporate BP’s human tsunami in the Gulf, “…..but we need to get a clear and loud message to BP that we, the nation, are not happy and we blame them for what’s happened,” you wrote.

I know what I think about the decision-makers responsible for the worst oil spill ever. But I wanted input from others. To that end, I took your comments to the street so-to-speak and conducted a rather unscientific poll.

Everybody agreed punitive damages are mandatory in the face of leadership that allows for the destruction of the environment while also bankrupting lives. The only way a message can be sent to those who take such gambles is for them to lose pay, bonuses, stock options and other perks. We must cease rewarding bad behavior in corporate America.

Like so many court judgments that end up overturned, imposing such penalties in this case would be easier said than done, however.

Moreover it is misguided to slap the decision-makers on the wrist while punishing BP stockholders. This does little to send a message to oil execs with other producers. Perhaps the BP board received an advanced notice of this blog, given the news that they replaced Tony Hayward as BP’s CEO recently.

I’d like to know what other ideas are out there on how to “get a clear and loud message to BP.” As one of my friends said, “BP got caught, but what about other oil companies? Are they in good shape so this kind of thing does not happen to their companies, their customers and the environment that belongs to us all?"

Let’s talk about it. And let's talk about how we, in the meat industry, can learn from the mistakes here. We all know, sometimes too well, how one bad apple can spoil the bunch.

You must register or login in order to post comments.

Market Video

Multimedia

Videos

Photos

Podcasts

The impact of the Food Safety Modernization Act
Tom Chestnut, vice president for Supply Chain Food Safety and Quality for NSF International, discusses the impact of the Food Safety Modernization Act.
More Podcasts

National Provisioner

NP Jan 2012 Cover

2012 January

Check out the January 2012 National Provisioner
TABLE OF CONTENTS SUBSCRIBE

Independent Processor

Independent Processor Dec. 2011

2011 December

Check out the December 2011 Independent Processor
TABLE OF CONTENTS SUBSCRIBE

Provisioner Store

Poultry Meat Processing
Poultry Meat Processing, Second Edition

When the first edition of Poultry Meat Processing was published, it provided a complete presentation of the theoretical and practical aspects of poultry meat processing, exploring the complex mix of biology, chemistry, engineering, marketing, and economics involved. Upholding its reputation as the most comprehensive text available, Poultry Meat Processing, Second Edition is thoroughly expanded and updated.

More Products

Sourcebook

SourcebookA complete reference guide to supplies. Go to NP's Sourcebook now to check out the latest and greatest in the meat and poultry processing business.

STAY CONNECTED

facebooklogo twitterlogo  linkedinlogo