Meat and Poultry Industry News

Hallmark to pay $500 million “symbolic” deterrent in animal abuse case

November 19, 2012
/ Print / Reprints /
/ Text Size+

The former owners of Hallmark Meat Packing Co. will pay $317,000 to settle a landmark federal fraud lawsuit over animal cruelty. The former owners of the plant, Donald Hallmark Sr. and Donald Hallmark Jr., also agreed to a final judgment of $497 million, which was called a symbolic deterrent, as the company declared bankruptcy after the 2008 incident and resulting recall, reports USA Today.

The Humane Society of the United States secretly recorded and released a videotape of workers using electric prods, hoses and forklifts to get downer cattle to walk or be taken into slaughter. The video caused an immediate uproar that eventually led to the largest meat recall in U.S. history.

The lawsuit -- filed under the False Claims Act of 1863 -- accused the nine defendants of defrauding the federal government by not treating animals humanely, which is required to be a school lunch contractor. The suit was initially filed by the HSUS, and the Justice Department joined the lawsuit in 2009. The Hallmarks agreed to cooperate.

A settlement has yet to be reached with the remaining defendants: Steve Mendell, president of Westland/Hallmark; Anthony Magidow, general manager of Westland/Hallmark and administrator for the estate of his father Aaron Magidow, a partner in the meat companies; and various partner companies – Westland/Hallmark, Hallmark Meat Packing, Westland Meat Co., M&M Management LLC and Cattleman’s Choice.

"I'm glad it's over," the senior Hallmark, 78, told the Riverside Press-Enterprise. "I wasn't even there when this thing started; I was retired. I'm just stuck in this case because I don't know why."

Most of the settlement payments will go to the federal government; the Humane Society will receive $12,672 for its role in prosecuting the case.

Sources: USA Today, Riverside Press-Enterprise

You must login or register in order to post a comment.



Image Galleries


Brenneman analyzes Butterball’s new animal care, well-being program

Rod Brenneman, CEO of Butterball, discusses his company's new Animal Care and Well-Being Program, his company's certification by the American Humane Association and further animal-handling initiatives, all officially announced in September 2013.

More Podcasts

National Provisioner


December 2014

The December issue of NP features a cover story on the GNP Company, an article on animal welfare, the 2015 economic outlook, and so much more!


Table Of Contents Subscribe

Independent Processor


December 2014

The December issue of IP features cover story: A full Haus, Mike Sloan’s award-winning bratwursts draw visitors to the Hermann Wurst Haus by the thousands.

Table Of Contents Subscribe

Provisioner Store

The National Provisioner Source Book

The Sourcebook is an exclusive buyer’s guide and reference tool for product and supplier information in the meat, poultry and seafood marketplace.

More Products


A complete reference guide to supplies. Go to NP's Sourcebook now to check out the latest and greatest in the meat and poultry processing business.


Facebook icon Twitter icon  YouTube iconLinkedIn icon google +

Vertical Sector Focus: Critical Infrastructures

criticalhomepagethumbFrom terrorism to vandalism, it’s preparedness, response, training and partnerships. Learn about some of the critical security issues facing this sector.

Visit the Critical Infrastructure page to read more.